What is a Topic?

The most mysterious term that I encountered a lot recently is topic. I have no idea how to define it and, neither seem the weblog research proposals that suggest finding the topic of a post is something worth doing. Being on holiday currently, and given it was raining and snowing outside, I tried to apply the notion of "topic finding'' to weblog conversations (see also: here, and here).

In Making a Difference terms used by bloggers in a "community" were compared with the objective to determine terms (topic?) that interested individual bloggers but not the entire community. This time, the source was a weblog conversation (loosely a collection of linked posts in a community) and determine what distinguishes a conversation compared to what the community usually blogs about (topic?). Three examples are shown in the table below (first number is frequency of term in the conversation, second number is score of term with respect to conversation vs. other posts inside the community).

Conversation 1	Conversation 2	Conversation 3
social tool [33, 19.3] tool [89, 18.5] blogwalk [40, 15.8] conference [54, 14.0] people [117, 13.6] blog [127, 12.6] blogtalk [34, 12.3] symposium [18, 11.9] experience [43, 11.8] event [33, 11.0]	sigmund [36, 31.9] blog [183, 26.7] blog research [29, 20.6] research [63, 20.1] analysis [37, 20.1] post [79, 19.5] conceptualisations [21, 19.0] paper [39, 16.2] rss [35, 12.9] study [30, 12.0]	presence [90, 38.3] skype [84, 32.8] communication [59, 27.5] im [40, 26.0] communication tool [23, 21.4] blog [129, 19.5] medium [31, 19.0] social [70, 18.0] tool [58, 17.4] quality [34, 15.7]

Conversation 1 is about the BlogWalk 3.0 event (experience, conference, symposium) which took place just before BlogTalk.

Conversation 2 is about Sigmund (the Sigmund paper is called "Shared Conceptualisations in Weblogs").

Conversation 3 is about Skype.

Although I'm still at a loss explaining why the methods I use work so well, it is clear that the notion of what a "topic" is has not been solved (is it the conjunction of the "most significant terms against some baseline"?). I'll check with my colleagues once I've returned from holidays :-).

One thing is crystal clear though: weblog research is more interesting when one concentrates on a well-defined subset of the blogosphere.

Comments

[Lilia]

Anjo,
wondering if it makes sense to use ratio of the frequency of term in the conversation / number of posts in a conversation? Wouldn't change the results for a specific conversation, but would make comparison easier...

Also - I'd expect that "topic" should be well represented with Sigmind picture for the given terms.

[Aleks]

My own definition is:
==
A topic is a semantic annotation of a document that people instinctively use to search and organize information. While we can semantically annotate many facets of a document, the notion of topic covers the document as a whole: it is the conceptualization of the document with the greatest breadth. When we seek information, our primary intention is usually to discover information on the same topic as is the topic of our problem. Topic can be distinguished from other descriptors of a document, such as language, style, punctuation, grammar, reputation, graphical design, author, date, and so on.
==

BTW, you can see how topics can be visualized graphically at [cosco.hiit.fi]. This is based on the open-source software for identification of topics from [componentanalysis.org].

[Anjo]

Lilia, I'm using the ratio. Stupid I missed the Sigmund metric on first hand (perhaps I am on holiday :-)).

Aleks, I think your definition is sort of the right direction, but fail to see how to operationalise it in any rigorous manner. Browsing the links you provided I became a little wiser :-). Thanks.

[JoseAngel]

Perhaps one cannot dissociate the definition of what is a "topic" from what does "going off-topic" mean in a specific context. Topics can grow, evolve, as further aspects are unearthed or perceived, and they can be contested... that is, you cannot take the topic as a given, it is shaped by the ongoing conversation.

[BrobiValki]

Get your FREE PS3 System here http://bit.ly/freeps3system

Don't pay for it when you can get it for free..

Pass the message around.

[JuliaKexgrefegof]

Handbags are no longer just items of practicality, but have become a symbol of style and self-identification and the demand for fashionable designer handbags shows no sign of slowing.

From practical to flamboyant, fashionable brand names create any and every size, style or color to pique every woman's unique desire for style. As with any accessory, handbags also serve as an extension of the wearer's personality; whether or not you're flashy or low-key, you can find a bag that suits every outfit or mood.

Today's fashion designer handbags cost upward of $1000 or more, and even if you can afford one, it's inevitable that a new "it" bag will come along next month, making yours dated. Not only are designer replica handbags a fraction of the price, many even have the signature designer insignia - making them practically identical to each other.

Most women long for a brand name to wear on their arm, but most cannot afford the $1000 or more price tags on these designer handbags. There are many designer inspired handbags just as good looking as the originals.

Some advantages of designer inspired handbags are that they're vastly more affordable than a major designer label. They match the current trend, and the craftsmanship of some is so good that distinguishing between a replica and a real bag is becoming increasingly difficult.

If you're worried about the lack of authenticity, designer inspired handbags are by no means cheap knockoffs of a real bag. They serve the same purpose and, in many cases, are made from the same material as an original, which means the only thing you're paying extra for is the name and where it's made (usually China or Italy).

Online is a great place to search for designer handbags (replica or non), including styles made popular by Luis Vuitton, Gucci, Coach and Christian Dior. Since replicas have become such a big trend, manufacturers and retailers give more attention to detail, ensuring that your bag will look identical to the most popular designer labels.

The major concern when buying designer handbags of the replica variety is figuring out if they share the quality of an original. Here are some tips:

Only buy replica handbags labeled "inspired by" instead of those that claim to be authentic. There should be small, but visible differences so that the replica bag has the look and feel of the designer bag that inspired it.

Still be prepared to pay a good amount of money for a quality replica designer purse ($200-$500 range). The "designer inspired" version will not require thousands of dollars, but still expect to pay for things like quality and hand stitching.

When shopping online look for disclaimers. If the disclaimer states that the handbag is inspired by or in the style of the designer, rather than a copy of the designer original or falsely claiming to be authentic, you won't be breaking any laws by buying one. Reputable companies will issue valid disclaimers and they will sell quality merchandise. Carefully examine any company selling replica purses for the quality, workmanship and customer service feedback.

Replica handbags will still cost you a weeks' salary - so make sure the quality is worth it. Just because you are buying a replica doesn't mean you should settle for poor construction or cheap materials. Know the quality of the original to know if the quality of the replica is acceptable.

Choosing replica handbags involves more than thinking you've found a deal that's too good to be true from a street vendor for $50. Just do a little homework - understand the disclaimer statement, become familiar with designer quality and carefully examine replica handbags before purchasing.

For great designer inspired handbags visit http://all-hand-bags.com/louis-vuitton-replica>bag louis replica vuitton on All-Hand-Bags.com .You are welcome :)

[SwibicyViassy]

Easy contact, fast answer, easy checkin fir the availability of the girl by the hours grid on the website. right choiche of anonym and good hotel...for me the best agency look http://lunaescort.net/ booking by sms tel.: +7 911 080 86 46 or email [email protected] i met Scheila in Paris! I had a fabulous first set with her. She liked a lot my daty but she got really high with fingering and, boys, did you noticed how blow jobs get better after a vaginal orgasm?
I understand that a girl may not have a lot of orgasm each day so I can’t complain if the second set was not that great.

[Reippidgidofs]

Car Recommendations When Buying a New, Used Car

When looking for a car to buy, there are many options out there. I have owned or driven just about every major manufacturer of imports that there are. Subaru makes one of the best all around vehicles for the money. I live in upstate New York and we get a good amount of snow here. The standard AWD that comes in all Subaru's is key to getting around in the winter. Business doesn't stop when it snows a foot. I have seen and been in many car accidents due to the snow, but never in my Subaru. It is safe to say that Subaru makes one of the best cars for snowy conditions in the world.

Buy a vehicle that has a Standard Transmission

Vehicles with Standard Transmissions rather than a Automatic Transmission give you a lot more control over the vehicle. The Standard Transmission allows you to down shift when slowing down. This helps in snowy or rainy conditions. Down shifting also helps to make the brakes on your car last longer. Along with those two points, a Standard Transmission car is just fun to drive all around. The driver is actually engaged in the driving experience rather than just tapping the gas pedal or brake pedal, the driver actually makes the car move and change gears physically by using the clutch.

Look at many options

Don't focus solely on a dealership. There are many different outlets that one can look into when looking for a new or used car. Certain websites allow people to post their vehicles up for sale for a fee while other physical car dealerships have websites with their cars on them. While buying from a dealership is usually the easiest way, it is not always the most cost effective. Dealerships tend to mark up the prices on their cars a lot so that they can make money on the deal. When you deal with a private party you can negotiate a little more with them to try to get the vehicle for the cost you want to pay.

http://utuma.com/toyota-4runner>1998 Toyota 4runner

[Reippidgidofs]

Things To Consider When Buying A Used Car

You are ready to buy a used car? Make sure you know certain things about cars because there are dealers or even private people who try to sell cars overpriced or even damaged ones. This article deals with several details that you want to consider before buying a used car.

Always have a closer look at the car before buying it. This includes several parts of the car that we will discuss right here.

1. The mileage

An older car will have a higher mileage but sometimes you can find cars that were driven for less than 5000 miles a year. An average consumer will drive between 12,000 and 16,000 miles a year. Those cars with a high usage are usually those that won't make you happy.

2. Inspect the engine

Have somebody with you who knows a lot about cars because the engine of a car is the most important thing to look at before buying the vehicle. A good clean looking engine is not always an indicator for a good working engine. The owner might have washed it just to achieve a higher price for the car.

Always test drive the car, this way you might find a technical problem. People who know a lot about cars can sometimes tell, just from hearing the engine sound, if the engine is alright or not.

3. Check the body of the car

Look for rusty areas and damages, check the whole body of the car. Look at areas near the bottom, these are the places where the rust spreads first.

4. Frame damages

Make sure that the car did not have an accident. Some car dealers try to sell a damaged cars, sometimes even with frame damages. These can be very dangerous for the new owner, so check the car carefully.

5. The Tires

Make sure all 4 tires are in a good condition. Look at the profile and check if the material is in a smooth condition. Make sure there aren't any damages at the tires, they are your life insurance!

6. Safety Features

Some old cars don't meet today's safety standards. It is up to you what level of safety standard you choose with your used car, just make sure the ones that are included work.

7. The price

Before buying a car, you want to compare the prices for the car model that you desire. You can use the internet for this issue. This way you can protect yourself from overpriced car deals. Take your time to research the whole topic, don't be in a hurry when buying a car. If you take the time to compare different offers you will certainly get a better deal and a better time with you car.

If you don't know much about cars, it is strongly adviced to a companion who is an expert in this topic. There are just too many people out there who try to fool you so be prepared for it. Once you are sure that the car of your desire is in a good condition you can start to negotiate about the price. Find the right price for the right car and you can enjoy your new used car!

http://utuma.com/mercury>Mercury Outboards

[jonlopes]

FXPLUS.ORG Bonus at registration from 10 to 50 %!

Term of Promo of the Action till January, 10th, 2010!

At account opening on:

from 100 $ to 1000 $ you to the account + 10%
from $ 200 to $ 2000 in your account + 20%
from $ 300 to $ 3000 in your account + 30%
from 400 $ to 4000 $ you on account + 40%
from 500 $ to 5000 $ and more to you on account + 50%

Charge of percent only on the working days!
Bonus percent and the deposit do not act in film, deduced only!

Stable payments! Join!

http://fx-plus.org/?ref=jon

[Miles]

I agree with the author. Thanks
http://www.rapidsharemix.com

[buy viagra]

You can use the internet for this issue. This way you can protect yourself from overpriced car deals. Take your time to research the whole topic, don't be in a hurry when buying a car

[LowerLadySheriff]

Now that cannabis has been reclassified, does it remain legal to own the seeds?
A company are using our business address as a "return to sender" address, I suppose in an attempt to not get caught. We tried to take them to the Police Station in the Summer but they wouldn't take them because it was legal to own cannabis (marijuana) seeds.

[generic propecia]

Take your time to research the whole topic, don't be in a hurry when buying a car

[beebrorpoto]

Women's Health
Cystitis is inflammation of the urinary bladder due to infection with some bacteria.
Women are especially susceptible to bacteria that may invade the urinary tract. Take care!
Your doctor should prescribe you a trusted and proven drug to treat Urinary Tract Infections.
Yeast infection treatment may not a difficult thing, provided you use an effective medication.
Do you know what the majority of American women choose to treat Urinary Tract Infections?
Women who change sexual partners may experience bladder or urinary tract infections more often.
Although most urinary tract infections are not serious, they can be painful. Use trusted drugs!
A small per cent of women have no problems and disorders during their menopause. Are you in?
Fortunately urinary tract infections are easily treated with antibiotics. What is your proven drug?
Some women are more prone to repeated urinary tract infections. You need a powerful weapon!
About 50 percent of all women experience at least one urinary tract infection in her lifetime.
Bacteria from the bowel are the most common cause of the majority of urinary tract infections.
Sexual intercourse is a common cause of urinary tract infections. Learn how to protect yourself!
Some women get a urinary tract infection every time they have sex. Only antibiotics can help!
Sharp pain or burning sensation in the urethra are the symptoms of UTI or bladder infection.
Antibiotics are the usual treatment for bladder and other urinary tract infections. Choose your one!
Symptoms of bladder infection may disappear soon after taking antibiotics. Take the full course!
Good personal hygiene is vital to prevent urinary tract infections. But sometimes it’s not enough.
Urinary tract infections are rather painful, but they are easy to treat with effective antibiotics.
Properly diagnosed and treated urinary tract infections last a few days. Make your choice now!
Genital herpes is a contagious viral infection that affects more than 20 per cent of Americans.
Do you know what you have to do to reduce your risk of vaginal infections? The answer is…
If you are being treated for a vaginal infection, use all the medication as your doctor prescribed.
Learn what you have to do to avoid hot flashes, night sweats, and headache during menopause.
The new American medication to relieve the symptoms of menopause helped hundreds of women!
If menopause means insomnia, depression, weight gain and fatigue for you – read this article!
If your pregnancy runs with plenty of disorders like vomiting, fatigue and insomnia, try this!
Effective medication takes as prescribed may greatly relieve the symptoms of menopause!
Hot flashes, fatigue and night sweats have spoiled lives of hundreds of women! Protect yourself!
Stupid women complain about hard menopause. Clever women take appropriate medication!
Prenatal vitamins promote not only your baby’s development, but your own physical health also.
Experienced gynecologists consult women on-line! Ask your question about vaginal infections!
Yeast infection treatment is not that expensive to suffer trying to save money! Use our discount!
Urinary tract disorders are common in pregnancy. Learn how to treat it and protect your baby.
Most therapists don’t know yet about the innovative bladder infection treatment! Get the info!
If you are pregnant you are more prone to different vaginal and urinary infections that before.
You should never forget about proper personal hygiene. But sometimes you need an antibiotic!
Even if you have never experienced a bladder infection it’s better to have a trusted drug at home!
Buy a proven urinary infection treatment at a discount. Boost your health and save your money!
Vomiting and dizziness may turn your pregnancy into a horror story! Stop the symptoms now!
Sickness and insomnia in pregnancy endanger not only you baby’s health, but your own as well.
If you belong to those women who have no symptoms in pregnancy, relax and enjoy this period!
Women taking no medications for pregnancy disorders endanger their physical and mental health
Certain urinary infections don’t let you sleep at night and act reasonably. Try our antibiotics!
Urinary tract infections for many women are associated with sleepless nights of constant itching.
Morning sickness in pregnancy can be relieved with premium women’s health medications!
The innovative al-natural pills easily relieve all most common symptoms of pregnancy.
Health disorders and problems during pregnancy make you regret you've decided to have a baby?
Painful periods are too painful sometimes! Help yourself to a trusted and powerful medication!
If you life stops for 4-5 days every month, try this medication for women and enjoy the life!
Prenatal vitamins are essential for your baby’s proper development! Ensure it’s ok!
Learn about the newest methodic of numerous specifically female diseases treatment.
The majority of female disorders are very delicate in treatment. Choose only trusted drugs!
For a woman it is vitally important to choose proper medication when in pregnancy!
Consult your doctor if you think you experience the symptoms of a urinary infection!
Make sure to consult your doctor if you need some medicine to relieve pregnancy symptoms
Non-medical home treatment of urinary infections is not only stupid, but also dangerous.
Even if you have a minor bladder infection you should take only trusted, prescribed drugs!
Find out which urinary tract infections treatment is the most trusted among American women!
Your health is not eternal. Don't take experimental medications! Choose trusted medicine!
All-natural medications for bladder infections treatment! Do you know about side effects?
Are you aware of the numerous risks experimental medicine brings to women’s health?
Pregnancy may be much more pleasant if you take proper symptoms relieving medications.
Top 10 most effective ways to treat urinary tract infections. Which one is your choice?
New British cystitis treatment makes a revolution in women’s health medication industry.
Proper personal hygiene regime ensures you health. Make sure you know the rules!
Ideal vaginal infections treatment is different for every woman. Consult your therapist today!
Let health into your life! Try the innovative women’s health medications for every disorder!
Female health medications claim to boost you health! Do you really believe it's possible?
Burning sensations when you have a bladder infection can be eliminated with a single pill!
You are not alone in your struggle with urinary infections! We are here to offer the treatment!
Personal hygiene is not only a tradition of the society but a proven way to stay healthy as well.
Sometimes a single vaginal infection may spoil your whole life forever! Be protected!
If you are suffering from vaginitis this medication is for you! It has shown 90% efficiency!
We are proud to present this innovative women’s health medication! Don’t miss the chance!
Only this month medications for female health are sold at half price! Hurry up to buy!
A unique time limited offer! Vaginitis treatment at a discount price available this week only!
Try this premium medication and make sure it is easy to get rid of urinary infection symptoms!
With the new antibiotic for cystitis treatment you may be sure of your health and wellness!
Don’t miss the ultimate fall clearance sale! All women’s health medications at a discount!
This is you last chance to save big shopping on our website for world most trusted medications!
Your health and wellness is just a matter of choice! What female medications do you choose?
We offer you a perfect chance to try some most popular prenatal vitamins and antibiotics!
We understand the ultimate importance of the prenatal vitamins quality for your baby’s health!
Don’t be stupid to think that your vaginal infection will end by itself! Use proven medications!
Every second person in the world has experienced a urinary tract infection. How do you treat it?
Everything you need to protect your health from vaginal and bladder infections! Learn more!
There are many drugs for vaginal infection treatment but only few of them are effective!
We’ve conducted a sociological survey to discover the most nation’s trusted prenatal vitamins!
Everything you need for trouble-free, healthy and pleasant pregnancy. Flexible prices and terms!
Suffering from vaginal infection? Free shipment of any medications and supplies you need!
World best female health medications with guaranteed effect! Get rid of your problems forever!
100 priceless tips for those women who haven't found their ideal vaginal infection treatment!
Pay attention to our offer of the month! The most trusted medications for women’s health!
If you know what pregnancy symptoms are, you’ll understand our desire to find the best drug!
Every woman knows the importance of effective urinary tract infections medication!
My doctor prescribed this medicine for me when I was suffering from vaginitis. It worked!
I wouldn’t bear my pregnancy if it weren’t for this excellent symptoms relieving medication!
My grandmother always used this method to eliminate urinary infections! No drugs needed!
Say good-bye to vaginitis, urinary infections, cystitis and other illnesses of the past!

http://pillstabletsrxdrugs.net>Look this

[viagra online]

These can be very dangerous for the new owner, so check the car carefully.

[viagra no prescription]

Have somebody with you who knows a lot about cars because the engine of a car is the most important thing to look at before buying the vehicle. A good clean looking engine is not always an indicator for a good working engine. The owner might have washed it just to achieve a higher price for the car.

[tyncclota]

This is the new Vs. thread...back from the dead!!! In here, as in the last thread, you may speculate,tell the facts, or just lie about the three new systems!
That's what Hell Billy,Mike, did with his original, so let's continue the tradition.
Everyone has thoughts about the whole system fight and with there being 3 months till Wii and PS3 and the debate going to continue after the three are out, this thread is for them thar fightin' words.
This will also fill the void we may each have by not getting our daily post by Mayor Mortis saying "Wii." You know you've missed it!!!

[illulmody]

where is all the maximum the hormone?

http://bestringtones_1.byethost3.com>ringing music

[How to Lose Weight]

I think the topic to something like that category where you can place special objects in order to categorize them

[amussysmogue]

What kinds of sex you know? Why it's positive for your health? How many sex you have for one week?

[buying land miramar puntarenas costa rica]

You have a startling blog. Thanks for escalating my awareness. I was not well-known with it. For more update I will stay more. I am plagued with your illustration. Thanks for giving out your entertainer mind's eye.

[Podurbiloa]

Next job: I want to offer inspiration to all who may read my story. Just always remember to stand strong and never let life or someone get you down. If you want something bad enough, you will find a way to make it happen. It may seem so overwhelming to you now, but it will happen in Gods will. If you can stay focused and have tunnel vision, all your dreams come true. For any questions please feel free to contact me by e-mail - things have been really busy, but if you can't tell we are CRAZY behind on scans on the site. so if anyone has any scans from magazines that are no longer on stands that they could send in, that'd be great! i'm going to try to pick up some magazines this week and get some massive scanning done. Redgrave was born in London, England to IMDb cannot vouch for the user experience provided by external sites; Edit by Dot: We Have A New Layout! Made By Auie! Which Is So FABULOUS! LOLZ! Lets Really Thank Auie For All She Has Done! And Here's Another Thing She Has Done... Vacation (1971) The Trojan Women (1971) Murder on the Orient Express (1974) Out of Season or doing SOMETHING, to make ends meet.

http://www9.kinghost.com/amateur/sexius/fake-vagina-making-instructions.html>Fake vagina making instructions

[kneeveSkymn]

A dog can be your best friend when it comes to home security.

Burglar alarms are not the be-all and end-all of home security. There are plenty of other things you can install in your home that will help to stop a burglar from gaining entry – and many of them are very simple and inexpensive.

The key is to secure the possible points of entry. This means that doors should be made of strong, solid material (definitely not plastic or glass), be properly secured to their hinges and have tamper-resistant locks. Ideally, you should have an extra deadbolt that you put on at night, made from very strong metal.

Windows should be made from toughened glass, preferably double-glazed, so that they are almost impossible to break. Although window locks are relatively uncommon, they help greatly with security, and you should consider installing them. If your house has windows in a position where they can be easily and discreetly accessed from the street, such as basement windows, you should consider putting metal bars on them.

It is also important for your garden to be secure, as far more burglars enter through the back of your house than the front. This means that your fences should be high and have some kind of anti-climbing measures (spikes or anti-climb paint can work well). If you don’t like fences, get big hedges instead.

Another thing to consider is getting a dog – surprisingly effective against burglars, who don’t generally want to mess with dogs if they can avoid it. For this strategy to be more effective, put up a ‘beware of the dog’ sign. Smaller dogs are not so great for this because they are not generally scary – something like a big German Shepherd works best, not only because of their size, but because of their strong guard instincts that cause them to be hostile to strangers.

The great security website http://securityprofs.com/>securityprofs.com. Really professional security.

[online pharmacy]

This time, the source was a weblog conversation (loosely a collection of linked posts in a community) and determine what distinguishes a conversation compared to what the community usually blogs about (topic?).